| Winners | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Crusaders | 9 | ||
| Blues | 3 | ||
| Bulls | 3 | ||
| Chiefs | 2 | ||
| Brumbies | 2 | ||
| Waratahs | 1 | ||
| Hurricanes | 1 | ||
| Highlanders | 1 | ||
| Reds | 1 | ||
| Year | Winners | Score | Runners-up |
| 1996 | Blues | 45–21 | Sharks |
| 1997 | Blues | 23–7 | Brumbies |
| 1998 | Crusaders | 20–13 | Blues |
| 1999 | Crusaders | 24–19 | Highlanders |
| 2000 | Crusaders | 20–19 | Brumbies |
| 2001 | Brumbies | 36–6 | Sharks |
| 2002 | Crusaders | 31–13 | Brumbies |
| 2003 | Blues | 21–17 | Crusaders |
| 2004 | Brumbies | 47–38 | Crusaders |
| 2005 | Crusaders | 35–25 | Waratahs |
| 2006 | Crusaders | 19–12 | Hurricanes |
| 2007 | Bulls | 20–19 | Sharks |
| 2008 | Crusaders | 20–12 | Waratahs |
| 2009 | Bulls | 61–17 | Chiefs |
| 2010 | Bulls | 25–17 | Stormers |
| 2011 | Reds | 18–13 | Crusaders |
| 2012 | Chiefs | 37–6 | Sharks |
| 2013 | Chiefs | 27–22 | Brumbies |
| 2014 | Waratahs | 33–32 | Crusaders |
| 2015 | Highlanders | 21–14 | Hurricanes |
| 2016 | Hurricanes | 20–3 | Lions |
| 2017 | Crusaders Scott Robertson | 25–17 | Lions |
| 2018 | Crusaders Scott Robertson | 37–18 | Lions |
| 2019 |
