| Club | Winners |
|---|---|
| Arsenal | 10 |
| Charlton Athletic | 3 |
| Fulham | 2 |
| Barnet | 2 |
| Blackburn Rovers | 2 |
| Tottenham Hotspur | 2 |
| Leeds United | 1 |
| Everton | 1 |
| Millwall Lionesses | 1 |
| Aston Villa | 1 |
| Sheffield | 1 |
| AFC Wimbledon Ladies | 1 |
| Sunderland | 1 |
| Season | Winner | Runner-up | Score | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1992 | Arsenal | Millwall Lionesses | 1–0 | Alt Park, Knowsley |
| 1993 | Arsenal | Knowsley | 3–0 | Wembley, London |
| 1994 | Arsenal | Doncaster Rovers Belles | 4–0 | Abbey Stadium, Cambridge |
| 1995 | Wimbledon | Villa Aztecs | 2–0 | Butlin Road, Rugby |
| 1996 | Wembley | Doncaster Rovers Belles | 2–2 (5–3 pens) | Underhill Stadium, Chipping Barnet |
| 1997 | Millwall Lionesses | Everton | 2–1 | Underhill Stadium, Chipping Barnet |
| 1998 | Arsenal | Croydon | 0–0 (4–2 pens) | Underhill Stadium, Chipping Barnet |
| 1999 | Arsenal | Everton | 3–1 | Prenton Park, Birkenhead |
| 2000 | Arsenal | Croydon | 4–1 | Underhill Stadium, Chipping Barnet |
| 2001 | Arsenal | Tranmere Rovers | 3–0 | Deva Stadium, Chester |
| 2002 | Fulham | Birmingham City | 7–1 | Adams Park, Wycombe |
| 2003 | Fulham | Arsenal | 1–1 (3–2 pens) | County Ground, Swindon |
| 2004 | Charlton Athletic | Fulham | 1–0 | Underhill Stadium, Chipping Barnet |
| 2005 | Arsenal | Charlton Athletic | 3–0 | Griffin Park, Brentford |
| 2006 | Charlton Athletic | Arsenal | 2–1 | Adams Park, Wycombe |
| 2007 | Arsenal | Leeds United | 1–0 | Glanford Park, Scunthorpe |
| 2008 | Everton | Arsenal | 1–0 | Brisbane Road, Leyton |
| 2009 | Arsenal | Doncaster Rovers Belles | 5–0 | Glanford Park, Scunthorpe |
| 2010 | Leeds Carnegie | Everton | 3–1 | Spotland, Rochdale |
| 2011 | Barnet | Nottingham Forest | 0–0 (4–3 pens) | Adams Park, Wycombe |
| 2012 | Sunderland | Leeds United | 2–1 | Sixfields Stadium, Northampton |
| 2013 | Aston Villa | Leeds United | 0–0 (5–4 pens) | Bootham Crescent, York |
| 2014 | Sheffield | Cardiff City | 6–2 | Pirelli Stadium, Burton upon Trent |
| 2015 | Charlton Athletic | Sheffield | 0–0 (4–2 pen.) | Liberty Way, Nuneaton |
| 2016 | Tottenham Hotspur | Cardiff City | 2–1 | Aggborough, Kidderminster |
| 2017 | Tottenham Hotspur | Charlton Athletic | 0–0 (4–3 pens) | Lamex Stadium, Stevenage |
| 2018 | Blackburn Rovers | Leicester City | 3–1 | Proact Stadium, Chesterfield |
| 2019 | Blackburn Rovers | Crawley Wasps | 3–0 | Pirelli Stadium, Burton upon Trent |