Copa Interamericana
| Year | Winner | Runner-up | 1st leg | 2nd leg | Playoff |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1969 | Estudiantes Osvaldo Zubeldía | Toluca | 2–1 Marcos Norberto Conigliaro, Carlos Salvador Bilardo / Felipe Ruvalcaba | 1–2 Juan Ramón Verón / Francisco Linares, Albino Morales | 3–0 Gabriel Eduardo Flores, Marcos Norberto Conigliaro (2) |
| 1972 | Nacional | Cruz Azul | 1–1 Juan Carlos Mamelli / Héctor Pulido | 2–1 Juan Carlos Mamelli, Braulio Castro / Fernando Bustos | — |
| 1973 | Independiente | Olimpia | 2–1 Alejandro Estanislao Semenewicz, Eduardo Andrés Maglioni / Jorge Brand | 2–0 Eduardo Andrés Maglioni, Agustín Alberto Balbuena | — |
| 1974 | Independiente | Municipal | 1–0 Ricardo Enrique Bochini | 0–1 José Emilio Mitrovich (4-2 pen.) | — |
| 1976 | Independiente José Omar Pastoriza | Atletico Español | 2–2 Ricardo Enrique Bochini, Víctor Arroyo / Oswaldo Ramírez, Juan Manuel Borbolla | 0–0 | — |
| 1978 | América Raúl Cárdenas | Boca Juniors | 0–3 Carlos Horacio Salinas (2), Ernesto Enrique Mastrángelo | 1–0 Hugo Enrique Kiesse | 2–1 José de Jesús Aceves, Carlos Reinoso / Daniel Pavón |
| 1980 | Olimpia Pedro Cubilla | FAS | 3–3 Alicio Solalinde, Evaristo Isasi (2) / Roberto Raúl Casadei (2), Amado Abraham | 5–0 Oswaldo Aquino, Miguel María Michelagnoli (3), Eduardo Ortiz | — |
| 1981 | UNAM Velibor "Bora" Milutinovic | Nacional | 3–1 Hugo Sánchez (2), Ricardo Ferreti / Víctor Espárrago | 1–3 Gustavo Vargas / Wilmar Cabrera (2), José Rosauro Cabrera | 2–1 Ricardo Ferreti , Gustavo Vargas / José Rosauro Cabrera |
| 1986 | Argentinos Juniors Roberto Saporiti | Defence Force | 1–0 Armando Javier Dely Valdez | — | — |
| 1987 | River Plate Carlos Timoteo Griguol | Alajuelense | 0–0 | 3–0 Jorge Villazán, Juan Gilberto Funes, Héctor Enrique | — |
| 1989 | Nacional Héctor Núñez | Club Deportivo Olimpia | 1–1 Daniel Fonseca / Belarmino Rivera | 4–0 Daniel Fonseca, Santiago Ostolaza, Luis Noé (2) | — |
| 1990 | Atlético Nacional Hernán Darío Gómez | UNAM | 2–0 Luis Alfonso Fajardo, Oscar Galeano | 4–1 Abraham Nava (og), Gustavo Restrepo, Oscar Galeano, Jaime Arango / Manuel Negrete | — |
| 1991 | Club América Carlos Miloc | Olimpia | 1–1 Eduardo de los Santos / Gabriel González | 2–1 Toninho (2) / Gabriel González | — |
| 1992 | Colo-Colo Mirko Jozic | Puebla | 4–1 Marcelo Pablo Barticciotto (3), Héctor Adomaitis / Silmar Olindo | 3–1 Hugo Rubio, Gabriel Mendoza, Héctor Adomaitis / Francisco Rotllán | — |
| 1994 | Universidad Católica Manuel Pellegrini | Saprissa | 1–3 Roy Myers / Rolando Fonseca, Javier Wanchope, Sergio Vázquez | 5–1 Andrés Romero, Alberto Acosta, Juvenal Olmos, Miguel Ardimán, Rodrigo Barrera / Javier Wanchope | — |
| 1996 | Vélez Sársfield Carlos Bianchi | Cartaginés | 0–0 | 2–0 José Oscar Flores (2) | — |
| 1997 | Atlético Nacional Norberto Peluffo | Saprissa | 3–2 Hernán Gaviria, Alex Comas, John Jaime Gómez / Javier Vicente Wanchope, Adrián Mahía | — | — |
| 1998 | D.C. United Bruce Arena | Vasco da Gama | 0–1 Felipe Jorge Loureiro | 2–0 Tony Sanneh, Eddie Pope | — |