| Club | Winners |
|---|---|
| Atlético Nacional | 4 |
| Millonarios | 3 |
| Boca Juniors | 2 |
| Independiente Medellín | 2 |
| Junior | 2 |
| Santa Fe | 2 |
| Deportes Tolima | 1 |
| Deportivo Cali | 1 |
| La Equidad | 1 |
| Season | Winner (Manager) | Score | Runner-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Copa Colombia | |||
| 1950–51 | Boca Juniors | Santa Fe | |
| 1951–52 | Boca Juniors | Millonarios | |
| 1952–53 | Millonarios | Boca Juniors | |
| 1963 | Millonarios | — | |
| 1981 | Independiente Medellín Leonel Montoya | Deportivo Cali | |
| 1989 | Santa Fe | Unión Magdalena | |
| Copa Colombia (Copa Postobón) | |||
| 2008 | La Equidad | 1-0 3-3 | Once Caldas |
| 2009 | Santa Fe | 1-2 José Yulián Anchico / Omar Rodriguez, Hugo Centurion 2-1 Omar Sebastián Pérez (2) / James Castro (5-4 pen.) | Deportivo Pasto |
| 2010 | Deportivo Cali | 1-0 Andrés Ramiro Escobar 2-0 César Amaya, Andrés Ramiro Escobar | Itagüí |
| 2011 | Millonarios | 1-0 1-0 | Boyacá Chicó |
| 2012 | Atlético Nacional Juan Carlos Osorio | 0-0 2-0 | Deportivo Pasto |
| 2013 | Atlético Nacional Juan Carlos Osorio | 2-2 1-0 | Millonarios |
| 2014 | Deportes Tolima | 2-0 1-2 | Santa Fe |
| Copa Colombia (Copa Águila) | |||
| 2015 | Junior F.C. | 2-0 0-1 | Santa Fe |
| 2016 | Atlético Nacional Reinaldo Rueda | 2-1 1-0 | Junior F.C. |
| 2017 | Junior F.C. | 1-1 2-0 | Independiente Medellín |
| 2018 | Atlético Nacional Jorge Almirón | 2-2 Aldo Leao Ramírez (2) / Eder Ricardo Steer (2) 2-1 Vladimir Javier Hernández, Daniel Eduardo Bocanegra / Johan Carbonero | Once Caldas |
| 2019 | Independiente Medellín Octavio Zambrano | 2-2 Didier Andrés Moreno, Germán Ezequiel Cano / Juan Ignacio Dinenno, Feiver Mercado 2-1 Adrián Arregui, Germán Ezequiel Cano / Daniel Alejandro Rosero | Deportivo Cali |