| Winners | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| United States | 9 | |||
| Mexico | 8 | |||
| Cuba | 1 | |||
| Costa Rica | 1 | |||
| Jamaica | 1 | |||
| Under-16 Tournament | ||||
| Year | Host | Champion | Score | 2nd Place |
| 1983 | Trinidad Tobago | United States | 0-0 (5-3 p.) | Trinidad and Tobago |
| Under-16 Championship | ||||
| 1985 | Mexico | Mexico | Final Round | Costa Rica |
| 1987 | Honduras | Mexico | Final Round | United States |
| 1988 | Trinidad Tobago | Cuba | Final Round | United States |
| Under-17 Tournament | ||||
| 1991 | Trinidad Tobago | Mexico | Final Round | United States |
| 1992 | Cuba | United States | Final Round | Mexico |
| 1994 | El Salvador | Costa Rica | Final Round | United States |
| Under-17 Championship | ||||
| 1996 | Trinidad Tobago | Mexico | Final Round | United States |
| Under-17 Tournament | ||||
| 1999 | Jamaica El Salvador | Jamaica Mexico | United States | |
| 2001 | United States Honduras | United States Costa Rica | - | |
| 2003 | Guatemala Canada | United States Costa Rica | Mexico | |
| 2005 | Costa Rica Mexico | United States Mexico | Costa Rica | |
| 2007 | Honduras Jamaica | Haiti United States | - | |
| U-17 Championship | ||||
| 2011 | Jamaica | United States Wilmer Cabrera | 3-0 Nathan Smith, Andrew Oliver, Alfred Koroma | Canada |
| 2013 | Panama | Mexico Raúl Gutiérrez | 2-1 Jaime De Garcia (og), Salomon Wbias / Jesus Araya | Panama |
| 2015 | Honduras | Mexico Mario Alberto Arteaga | 3-0 Kevin Magana, Claudio Zamudio, Ulises Torres | Honduras |
| 2017 | Panama | Mexico Mario Alberto Arteaga | 1-1 Carlos Robles / Andrew Carleton (5-4 p.) | United States |
| 2019 | United States | Mexico Mario Alberto Arteaga | 2-1 Santiago Muoz, Israel Luna / Griffin Yow | United States |
