| Season | Venue | Winner (Manager) | Score | Runners–up |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2011 | FNB Stadium | Orlando Pirates | 0-0 (4-3 pen.) | Kaizer Chiefs |
| 2012 | FNB Stadium | Orlando Pirates | 1-1 (5-4 pen.) | Kaizer Chiefs |
| 2013 | FNB Stadium | Kaizer Chiefs | 1-0 | Orlando Pirates |
| 2014 | FNB Stadium | Orlando Pirates | 0-0 (6-5 pen.) | Kaizer Chiefs |
| 2015 | FNB Stadium | Orlando Pirates | 1-1 Reneilwe "Yeye" Letsholonyane / Sifiso Myeni (4-3 pen.) | Kaizer Chiefs |
| 2016 | FNB Stadium | Kaizer Chiefs | 2-0 Eric "Tower" Mathoho, Lewis Macha | Orlando Pirates |
| 2017 | FNB Stadium | Kaizer Chiefs | 1-0 Bernard Parker | Orlando Pirates |
| 2019 | FNB Stadium | Orlando Pirates | 2-0 Augustine Kabaso Mulenga, Thembinkosi Lorch | Kaizer Chiefs |
