| Team | Winners |
| Tigres UANL | 1 |
| Atlanta United FC | 1 |
| Year | Host | Winner | Score | Finalist |
| 2018 | Toronto | Tigres UANL Ricardo Ferreti | 3-1 Jesus Duenas (2), Erig Zavaleta (og) / Lucas Janson | Toronto FC |
| 2019 | Atlanta | Atlanta United FC Frank De Boer | 3-2 Emerson Hyndman, Jeff Larentowicz, Josef Martinez / Renato Ibarra, Roger Martinez | Club America |