| Winners | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| River Plate | 36 | ||
| Boca Juniors | 34 | ||
| Racing | 18 | ||
| Independiente | 16 | ||
| San Lorenzo | 15 | ||
| Vélez Sarsfield | 10 | ||
| Alumni | 10 | ||
| Estudiantes (LP) | 6 | ||
| Newell's Old Boys | 6 | ||
| Huracán | 5 | ||
| Lomas | 5 | ||
| Rosario Central | 4 | ||
| Belgrano AC | 3 | ||
| Argentinos Juniors | 3 | ||
| Lanús | 2 | ||
| Ferro Carril Oeste | 2 | ||
| Porteño | 2 | ||
| Quilmes | 2 | ||
| Estudiantil Porteño | 2 | ||
| Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | 1 | ||
| Banfield | 1 | ||
| Lomas Academy | 1 | ||
| Arsenal | 1 | ||
| Chacarita Juniors | 1 | ||
| Dock Sud | 1 | ||
| Old Caledonians | 1 | ||
| Sportivo Barracas | 1 | ||
| St. Andrew's | 1 | ||
| Season | Champion | Score | Runner-up |
| 1891 | St. Andrew's & Old Caledonians | Buenos Aires and Rosario Railway | |
| 1893 | Lomas | Flores | |
| 1894 | Lomas | Rosario AC | |
| 1895 | Lomas | Lomas Academy | |
| 1896 | Lomas Academy | Flores | |
| 1897 | Lomas | Lanús AC [note 3] | |
| 1898 | Lomas | Lobos | |
| 1899 | Belgrano AC | Lobos | |
| 1900 | Alumni [note 4] | Lomas | |
| 1901 | Alumni | Belgrano AC | |
| 1902 | Alumni | Barracas | |
| 1903 | Alumni | Belgrano AC | |
| 1904 | Belgrano AC | Alumni | |
| 1905 | Alumni | Belgrano AC | |
| 1906 | Alumni | Lomas | |
| 1907 | Alumni | Estudiantes (BA) | |
| 1908 | Belgrano AC | Alumni | |
| 1909 | Alumni | River Plate | |
| 1910 | Alumni | Porteño | |
| 1911 | Alumni | Porteño | |
| 1912 | Quilmes | San Isidro | |
| 1912 FAF | Porteño | Independiente | |
| 1913 | Racing | San Isidro | |
| 1913 FAF | Estudiantes (LP) | Gimnasia y Esgrima (BA) | |
| 1914 | Racing Club | Estudiantes (BA) | |
| 1914 FAF | Porteño | Estudiantes (LP) | |
| 1915 | Racing Club | San Isidro | |
| 1916 | Racing Club | Platense | |
| 1917 | Racing Club | River Plate | |
| 1918 | Racing Club | River Plate | |
| 1919 | Boca Juniors | Estudiantes | |
| 1919 AAmF | Racing Club | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 1920 | Boca Juniors | Banfield | |
| 1920 AAmF | River Plate | Racing | |
| 1921 | Huracán | Del Plata | |
| 1921 AAmF | Racing | River Plate | |
| 1922 | Huracán | Sportivo Palermo | |
| 1922 AAmF | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1923 | Boca Juniors | Huracán | |
| 1923 AAmF | San Lorenzo | Independiente | |
| 1924 | Boca Juniors | Temperley | |
| 1924 AAmF | San Lorenzo | Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | |
| 1925 | Huracán | Nueva Chicago | |
| 1925 AAmF | Racing | San Lorenzo | |
| 1926 | Boca Juniors | Argentinos Juniors | |
| 1926 AAmF | Independiente | San Lorenzo | |
| 1927 | San Lorenzo | Boca Juniors | |
| 1928 | Huracán | Boca Juniors | |
| 1929 | Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | Boca Juniors | |
| 1930 | Boca Juniors Mario Fortunato | Estudiantes (LP) | |
| 1931 | Estudiantil Porteño | Almagro | |
| 1931 LAF | Boca Juniors Mario Fortunato | San Lorenzo | |
| 1932 | Sportivo Barracas | Barracas Central | |
| 1932 LAF | River Plate Víctor Caamaño | Independiente | |
| 1933 | Dock Sud | Nueva Chicago | |
| 1933 LAF | San Lorenzo | Boca Juniors | |
| 1934 | Estudiantil Porteño | Banfield | |
| 1934 LAF | Boca Juniors Mario Fortunato | Independiente | |
| 1935 | Boca Juniors Mario Fortunato | Independiente | |
| 1936 (H) | San Lorenzo | Huracán | |
| 1936 (C) | River Plate Emérico Hirschl | San Lorenzo | |
| 1936 (O) | River Plate Emérico Hirschl | San Lorenzo | |
| 1937 | River Plate Emérico Hirschl | Independiente | |
| 1938 | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1939 | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1940 | Boca Juniors | Independiente | |
| 1941 | River Plate Renato Cesarini | San Lorenzo | |
| 1942 | River Plate Renato Cesarini | San Lorenzo | |
| 1943 | Boca Juniors Alfredo Garasini | River Plate | |
| 1944 | Boca Juniors Alfredo Garasini | River Plate | |
| 1945 | River Plate José María Minella | Boca Juniors | |
| 1946 | San Lorenzo | Boca Juniors | |
| 1947 | River Plate José María Minella | Boca Juniors | |
| 1948 | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1949 | Racing Club Guillermo Stábile | River Plate | |
| 1950 | Racing Club Guillermo Stábile | Boca Juniors | |
| 1951 | Racing Club Guillermo Stábile | Banfield | |
| 1952 | River Plate José María Minella | Racing | |
| 1953 | River Plate José María Minella | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 1954 | Boca Juniors | Independiente | |
| 1955 | River Plate José María Minella | Racing | |
| 1956 | River Plate José María Minella | Lanús | |
| 1957 | River Plate José María Minella | San Lorenzo | |
| 1958 | Racing Club | Boca Juniors | |
| 1959 | San Lorenzo | Racing | |
| 1960 | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1961 | Racing Club | San Lorenzo | |
| 1962 | Boca Juniors | River Plate | |
| 1963 | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1964 | Boca Juniors | Independiente | |
| 1965 | Boca Juniors | River Plate | |
| 1966 | Racing Club | River Plate | |
| 1967 Met | Estudiantes (LP) Osvaldo Zubeldía | Racing | |
| 1967 Nac | Independiente | Estudiantes (LP) | |
| 1968 Met | San Lorenzo Elba de Pádua Lima | Estudiantes (LP) | |
| 1968 Nac | Vélez Sársfield | River Plate | |
| 1969 Met | Chacarita Juniors | River Plate | |
| 1969 Nac | Boca Juniors Alfredo Di Stéfano | River Plate | |
| 1970 Met | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1970 Nac | Boca Juniors | Rosario Central | |
| 1971 Met | Independiente | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 1971 Nac | Rosario Central | San Lorenzo | |
| 1972 Met | San Lorenzo Juan Carlos Lorenzo | Racing | |
| 1972 Nac | San Lorenzo Juan Carlos Lorenzo | River Plate | |
| 1973 Met | Huracán | Boca Juniors | |
| 1973 Nac | Rosario Central | River Plate | |
| 1974 Met | Newell's Old Boys | Rosario Central | |
| 1974 Nac | San Lorenzo Osvaldo Zubeldía | Rosario Central | |
| 1975 Met | River Plate Ángel Labruna | Huracán | |
| 1975 Nac | River Plate Ángel Labruna | Estudiantes (LP) | |
| 1976 Met | Boca Juniors Juan Carlos Lorenzo | Huracán | |
| 1976 Nac | Boca Juniors Juan Carlos Lorenzo | River Plate | |
| 1977 Met | River Plate Ángel Labruna | Independiente | |
| 1977 Nac | Independiente | Talleres (C) | |
| 1978 Met | Quilmes | Boca Juniors | |
| 1978 Nac | Independiente | River Plate | |
| 1979 Met | River Plate Ángel Labruna | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 1979 Nac | River Plate Ángel Labruna | Unión | |
| 1980 Met | River Plate Ángel Labruna | Argentinos Juniors | |
| 1980 Nac | Rosario Central | Racing (C) | |
| 1981 Met | Boca Juniors Silvio Marzolini | Ferro Carril Oeste | |
| 1981 Nac | River Plate Alfredo Di Stéfano | Ferro Carril Oeste | |
| 1982 Nac | Ferro Carril Oeste | Quilmes | |
| 1982 Met | Estudiantes (LP) Carlos Bilardo | Independiente | |
| 1983 Nac | Estudiantes (LP) Eduardo Luján Manera | Independiente | |
| 1983 Met | Independiente | San Lorenzo | |
| 1984 Nac | Ferro Carril Oeste | River Plate | |
| 1984 Met | Argentinos Juniors | Ferro Carril Oeste | |
| 1985 Nac | Argentinos Juniors | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 1985–86 | River Plate Héctor Veira | Newell's Old Boys | |
| 1986–87 | Rosario Central | Newell's Old Boys | |
| 1987–88 | Newell's Old Boys José Yudica | San Lorenzo | |
| 1988–89 | Independiente | Boca Juniors | |
| 1989–90 | River Plate Daniel Passarella | Independiente | |
| 1990–91 | Newell's Old Boys Marcelo Bielsa | Boca Juniors | |
| 1991 Ap | River Plate Daniel Passarella | Boca Juniors | |
| 1992 Cl | Newell's Old Boys Marcelo Bielsa | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 1992 Ap | Boca Juniors Oscar Tabarez | River Plate | |
| 1993 Cl | Vélez Sársfield Carlos Bianchi | Independiente | |
| 1993 Ap | River Plate Daniel Passarella | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 1994 Cl | Independiente | Huracán | |
| 1994 Ap | River Plate Américo Gallego | San Lorenzo | |
| 1995 Cl | San Lorenzo Héctor Veira | Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | |
| 1995 Ap | Vélez Sársfield Carlos Bianchi | Racing | |
| 1996 Cl | Vélez Sársfield Carlos Bianchi | Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | |
| 1996 Ap | River Plate Ramón Díaz | Independiente | |
| 1997 Cl | River Plate Ramón Díaz | Colón | |
| 1997 Ap | River Plate Ramón Díaz | Boca Juniors | |
| 1998 Cl | Vélez Sársfield Marcelo Bielsa | Lanús | |
| 1998 Ap | Boca Juniors Carlos Bianchi | Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | |
| 1999 Cl | Boca Juniors Carlos Bianchi | River Plate | |
| 1999 Ap | River Plate Ramón Díaz | Rosario Central | |
| 2000 Cl | River Plate Américo Gallego | Independiente | |
| 2000 Ap | Boca Juniors Carlos Bianchi | River Plate | |
| 2001 Cl | San Lorenzo Manuel Pellegrini | River Plate | |
| 2001 Ap | Racing Club Reinaldo Merlo | River Plate | |
| 2002 Cl | River Plate Ramón Díaz | Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | |
| 2002 Ap | Independiente Américo Gallego | Boca Juniors | |
| 2003 Cl | River Plate Manuel Pellegrini | Boca Juniors | |
| 2003 Ap | Boca Juniors Carlos Bianchi | San Lorenzo | |
| 2004 Cl | River Plate Leonardo Astrada | Boca Juniors | |
| 2004 Ap | Newell's Old Boys Américo Gallego | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 2005 Cl | Vélez Sársfield Miguel Ángel Russo | Banfield | |
| 2005 Ap | Boca Juniors Alfio Basile | Gimnasia y Esgrima (LP) | |
| 2006 Cl | Boca Juniors Alfio Basile | Lanús | |
| 2006 Ap | Estudiantes (LP) | Boca Juniors | |
| 2007 Cl | San Lorenzo Ramón Díaz | Boca Juniors | |
| 2007 Ap | Lanús Ramón Cabrero | Tigre | |
| 2008 Cl | River Plate Diego Simeone | Boca Juniors | |
| 2008 Ap | Boca Juniors Carlos Ischia | Tigre | |
| 2009 Cl | Vélez Sársfield Ricardo Gareca | Huracán | |
| 2009 Ap | Banfield | Newell's Old Boys | |
| 2010 Cl | Argentinos Juniors | Estudiantes (LP) | |
| 2010 Ap | Estudiantes (LP) Alejandro Sabella | Vélez Sársfield | |
| 2011 Cl | Vélez Sársfield Ricardo Gareca | Lanús | |
| 2011 Ap | Boca Juniors Julio Falcioni | Racing | |
| 2012 Cl | Arsenal Gustavo Alfaro | Tigre | |
| 2012 In | Vélez Sársfield Ricardo Gareca | Newell's Old Boys | |
| 2013 Fi | Newell's Old Boys Gerardo Martino | River Plate | |
| 2012–13 | Vélez Sársfield Ricardo Gareca | Newell's Old Boys | |
| 2013 In | San Lorenzo Juan Antonio Pizzi | Lanús | |
| 2014 Fi | River Plate Ramón Díaz | Boca Juniors | |
| 2014 Tr | Racing Club Diego Cocca | River Plate | |
| 2015 | Boca Juniors Rodolfo Arruabarrena | San Lorenzo | |
| 2016 | Lanús Jorge Almirón | San Lorenzo | |
| 2016–17 | Boca Juniors Guillermo Barros Schelotto | League System | River Plate |
| 2017–18 | Boca Juniors Guillermo Barros Schelotto | League System | Godoy Cruz |
| 2018–19 | Racing Club Eduardo Coudet | League System | Defensa y Justica |
| 2019–20 | Boca Juniors Miguel Ángel Russo | League System | River Plate |